NIMBY, YIMBY…and THIMBY?

A dispute in Chicago’s Lincoln Park neighborhood about a proposed Comed substation includes the involvement of a local THIMBY group:

Photo by Phil Evenden on Pexels.com

Driscoll, a Lakeview resident for more than half a century, is among thousands of locals caught up in a bitter fight over ComEd’s plans to build an electrical substation at 1111 W. Diversey Parkway. The utility maintains that the site is the best available option for equipment necessary to protect the area from blackouts and brownouts, while opponents argue the land should be used for housing instead.

But the monthslong dispute has devolved into a battle of competing narratives, with residents accusing ComEd of dishonesty and the utility insisting their critics misunderstand the project. For Driscoll, who belongs to the Diversey Community Coalition, or DCC, the stakes extend far beyond electrical infrastructure.

The coalition, a grassroots group formed earlier this year, has rallied more than a thousand residents against the substation. Rejecting the label of NIMBYism is central to the DCC’s identity, with members instead embracing a term of their own: THIMBYism, or “Transit-oriented Housing In My Backyard.”…

As the coalition tells it, the property could accommodate upwards of 200 apartments that house more than 450 people, including dozens of affordable units. Based on those estimates, the DCC says the development would generate another $5 million in annual neighborhood spending.

The pitch appears to be that they don’t want dangerous infrastructure in their neighborhood – and they proposed multiple alternative sites – but the group does want housing.

Many communities could benefit from housing, particularly if it is located near transportation options and corridors. Infrastructure also needs to be located somewhere and Comed already owns this land.

Is what unites NIMBY, YIMBY, or THIMBY the idea that local residents and/or leaders get to decide how land is used? And when these acronyms are connected to the efforts of wealthier communities, like Lincoln Park, it is a reminder of how development decisions are made.

It is too bad we don’t get parallel universes here that would let us see how different scenarios play out. Let’s say the substation gets moved; what does it then look like in the community with all the work it would take to approve transit-oriented development? Or if the substation is constructed, what happens next to promote housing in the community? Rallying against an undesirable land use might motivate neighbors but sustaining long-term community involvement to construct housing is a long-term project.

Even affluent Chicago neighborhoods, like Lincoln Park, have lost significant numbers of residents

Rust Belt cities like Chicago have declined in population since the mid-1900s and the population loss is not just limited to poorer neighborhoods:

For a long time, most accounts of Chicago’s lagging population have focused on parts of the South and West Sides where many residents, largely African-American, have decided to decamp for the suburbs or the South in search of better schools, less crime, and more jobs.But the under-appreciated flip side of population loss in those parts of the city is that places that ought to be growing like gangbusters are stagnant, often sitting 25% to 50% below their peak populations. Lakeview, for example, was once home to 124,000 people; its population is now 94,000. North Center is down from nearly 49,000 to under 32,000. West Town, which includes Wicker Park and Bucktown, has fallen from 187,000 to 81,000.

Decline5010

What explains the population loss in even popular neighborhoods? Here is one possible answer:

Since replacing a couple two-flats with a courtyard building is now illegal, developers make money by tearing down an old two-flat and building a luxury two-flat in its place. Or they build a mansion, and the neighborhood actually loses a housing unit. As a result, as a neighborhood becomes more attractive, the city encourages fewer people to live there.

Zoning (theoretically based on improving the neighborhood) plus chasing profits may just lead to population loss. This could be balanced out by approving more high-density housing in a particular area (like the Loop are in specific portions of popular neighborhoods as to limit their effect) but that leads to major changes in two places.

It is still worth noting that the areas that seen an increase in population are either (1) the Loop with a reemphasis on residential construction and (2) community areas on the edges of the city which other lower densities as well as potentially more open land since 1950.