Suburban school districts in the Chicago region that might need to make a case for closing schools

As Chicago political leaders and candidates debate closing schools (examples here and here), this raised for me a broader question: which Chicago area school districts in the coming years will make a positive case to the public for closing some schools and then actually close them?

Photo by RDNE Stock project on Pexels.com

A number of communities could face this as they relatively stagnant populations and declining birth rates. This is not true of all places; there are still parts of the Chicago region growing more rapidly or that have higher percentages of young families. But many communities have school districts and facilities sized to an earlier era of growth, whether that was immediately in the postwar decades for some places closer to Chicago or in the late twentieth and early twenty-first century in other places.

What case could they make to local residents about closing schools?

-Limiting property taxes or limiting future increases.

-Better allocation of resources to serve the needs of students, teachers, and others in the school district.

-Finding new uses for the buildings or land that can contribute positively to the community.

-Being responsive to changing communities.

Like there has been in Chicago, there will be residents and leaders who will make arguments against closing schools. Do suburban school districts have the processes ready and trust built up to facilitate conversations between those who would be for closures and against closures? Since at least some of the process of choosing a residence in suburbia is tied to schools, these could be intense conversations.

Or what would residents think of another option: consolidating or merging school districts? Suburbanites like local control over schools but mergers could take place between similar districts or communities.

Right now, this might sound to many in the Chicago region as an issue only Chicago is facing. That may not be the case in the next decade or two.

Suburban voters swing toward Democrats in 2026 elections

More voters in the country’s most populous setting voted for Democrats last week (according to the SSRS 2026 polling data on House races):

Even as urban voters are heavily Democratic and rural voters are more Republican, the suburban voters went more for Democrats. (My guess is that there is some overlap between suburban and small town here as the US urban population is around 80%.)

Urban and suburban voters were more likely to see their House vote as being cast against the current president:

When considering the most important issues in the election, voters in urban and suburban areas were more alike (with some slight differences in rural areas and small towns regarding immigration and democracy):

Both because the suburbs contain so many potential voters and there are some suburbanites who can be swayed (see how they voted in 2024), this will be something to watch for leading up to 2028. If the economy was the leading issue in 2026, what changes would influence suburban voters one way or the other?

What votes did Pope Leo cast in local suburban political races and questions?

Pope Leo voted in the 2026 American election cycle in suburban New Lenox, Illinois:

Photo by Sora Shimazaki on Pexels.com

Records show that the pope is registered under his baptismal name, Robert Francis Prevost, to vote in the Chicago suburb of New Lenox, where his brother John lives. The Chicago-born pontiff has cast ballots in both Republican and Democratic primaries in recent years and cast a vote in the 2024 presidential election….

The pope’s ballot is expected to include votes for the senate and governor race in Illinois, along with house of representative, state and county elections.

While there is interest in comparing the Pope’s political views versus that of the current US administration, I would be interested to know how he voted regarding local candidates and issues. As noted above, this includes voting for state and local elections. Local choices could include for county boards, forest preserves, local judges, and municipal governments. It might include local referendum issues about property tax increases for school district needs or other specific local questions. Local residents might struggle to keep up with all the local issues and all the names on signs that pop up at each election cycle, let alone someone who is living elsewhere and voting from a distance.

The shorthand the media often uses for state and national issues – it is Democrats vs. Republicans, one party wins and the other loses – do not always hold up in suburban elections. Sometimes they do; elections for county boards and school boards in the Chicago suburbs can now echo national party platforms. But sometimes they do not. There are local election slates. Or particular histories and character in communities that influence local elections. A suburban community may lean more Democratic or Republican in larger political races but the local political activity can be unique.

New Lenox, Illinois is a unique suburban community southwest of Chicago. It has grown rapidly in recent years, increasing from under 3,000 residents in 1970 to over 27,000 in 2020. The suburb is largely white with the 2020 Census finding over 87% were white alone. A 2015 promotional campaign for the community emphasized that it is “home to proud Americans.” How do leaders and residents understand their community’s character, considering past, present, and future, and how does this affect their vote?

After the election concludes, there will be data regarding races – national, state, and local – that New Lenox residents voted in. It sounds like the Pope’s votes will be part of this.

When suburban residents want their “nice town” to remain a “nice town”

In the last two decades, I have studied the trajectories of a number of suburban communities. There is a common pattern in the paths these suburbs have traveled: even as they have grown and changed, current residents want their suburb to stay the same. Or at least have the same features and character that existed when they moved to the community.

I found another example of this recently in a local history of Lombard, Illinois. After describing decade by decade what had happened in what was first known as Babcock’s Grove, Mildred Robinson Dunning ends The Story of Lombard: 1833-1955 this way:

Photo by Eugene Shirokov on Pexels.com

So now you have the STORY OF LOMBARD, a conservative suburban community of some 16,000 folk at the end of 1955, neither very rich nor very poor, a town built on gently rolling ground at the top of the ridge between Lake Michigan and the Fox River Valley, twenty miles west from Chicago. It is a dormitory town, a very large percent of its gainfully employed men and women finding employment outside of the town. Walk or drive down its lovely old streets, noting its homelike appearance with its well kept homes and lawns, beautiful shade trees, churches and school, parks and playgrounds. Say a “thank you” to the folk who, with foresight, persistence and patience, have made it the town that it is. It IS a nice town. So much for the past; the future of Lombard is pretty much up to all of us. Let’s keep it a nice town. (62)

These sentiments are not unusual in local histories: the founders were virtuous, the community has slowly grown, and it should continue going the way it has been. There is a hint of major change on the horizon – the population was 9,817 in 1950 while in 1960 it would have 22,561 on its way to a current population of over 44,000 – but Dunning suggests “Let’s keep it a nice town.”

What exactly does this mean? When she was writing, Lombard was not the same place it was in the 1830s and most of the 1840s before the railroad arrived and few people lived there. It was not the same place in 1955 as it was in the 1920s. One way to read this argument is that suburban residents do not want their community to lose the fundamentally attractive suburban features it had. Dunning notes that it is a bedroom community. It has “lovely old streets” with “well kept homes and lawns.” It has amenities for residents to enjoy. The people who lived there cared for it.

Another way to think about this argument is suburban residents fearing change and what might happen. If the community quadruples in size (as Lombard does between 1950 and 1980), does day to day life fundamentally change? Do these bucolic suburban features go away? Who are the new neighbors who will move in? Will Lombard continue to be stable, quiet, conservative?

Suburban communities rarely stay exactly the same for long. External forces and internal decisions push them in different directions. Local leaders and residents have a sense of what they think the community was and what they hope it might be. And it is easy to give in to thinking the suburb had a golden era where it was truly a suburban paradise.

Lombard residents and leaders might very tell today describe their suburb as a “nice town.” How they do so might differ from Dunning as seven decades have passed and Lombard is a larger and different suburban community. They, too, might say that they want Lombard to remain the place that it is rather than becoming something else that they would not like.

When “everyone is chasing water” in the suburbs

Suburban communities in Arizona are trying to make plans for supplying water in future decades. This could come with significant price hikes:

Photo by Q. Hu01b0ng Phu1ea1m on Pexels.com

To officials, Queen Creek is a model of how to confront the Southwest’s water woes head-on. The city expects to ultimately spend $730 million to tap into faraway groundwater, insulating themselves from drought for decades to come.

But a proposed “water resource fee” to fund the project has brought furious pushback from the highest water users in town, in a conservative place where leaders pride themselves on lowering taxes. It’s also renewed long-standing tensions over whether Queen Creek is expanding too fast for its resources, as city officials say they expect their population to nearly double by around 2050.

Other Southwest metropolises are facing similar questions about how to keep growing in arid places where water is scarce and getting more so. Arizona’s desert cities are in an especially tough position because they hold more junior water rights than other cities that draw on the Colorado River, such as Los Angeles, Las Vegas and San Diego…

The average single-family home would pay an extra $57 or $138 a month once the water fee is fully phased in, officials said, depending on the details of their usage…

Incorporated in 1989 as an agricultural community of just a couple thousand people, the city’s population has grown to about 90,000, and the water issue stoked doubts among some longtime residents that the rapid change was good for them and the town.

Rapid suburban growth presents a particular set of challenges, including establishing local infrastructure that can meet the current and future needs of the community. Water is essential to daily life but is not as easy to secure in some places compared to others.

While it sounds like current residents and officials are wrestling with how to pay for current and future needs, what might this do to forecasted suburban growth? Would a community turn down growth because of not having enough water? Or would people attracted by cheaper housing here say no to a house because of water prices or water uncertainty? Would growth in a metropolitan region significantly shift toward communities that have secured future water and prices?

This applies to water in Arizona but it might also apply to other community needs. If gas and electricity prices are higher because of power needs and grid concerns. If prices suddenly spike for constructing roads, bridges, and highways. A need for internet equipment but that material is not available. And so on.

The bigger picture issue might be this: the price of a house is important for Americans. This story discusses water and hints that the monthly costs of owning a home might significantly increase. For these homeowners in Arizona, can they predict water prices five or ten years down the road? The house might look reasonable now but utility bills can cause a lot of people problems.

Beyond Halloween, what would make a suburban home spooky to the neighbors

Inspired by seeing this request for photos of the spookiest house on the block, I thought of ways a suburban house could be spooky all year round. And by spooky I mean a threat to property values in the eyes of the neighbors. Here are some ways:

Photo by Yana Kangal on Pexels.com

-Don’t maintain the lawn and front yard. Long grass. Large weeds. Overgrown bushes. The backyard is more hidden so it might escape scrutiny. The front yard will be seen by everyone driving or walking by.

-Paint the house a bright and/or unusual color. Be way out of the ordinary in the color palette. Stand out. High contrast between the main color and the trim. Make people take notice.

-Leave the trash and recycling cans in a very visible location. Don’t put them away or screen them from public view. Remind everyone that the house generates refuse and recycling.

-Have holiday decorations up and on all year round. It is fun at the holiday season but keep the Christmas or Thanksgiving or Halloween or July 4th or big game decor up all the time. Have those red and green lights twinkling in late April.

-Park an unattractive vehicle or one clearly needing repair in the driveway for a long time. Let it sit without any positive changes.

I have seen some macabre Halloween yard scenes but these examples above might bother residents more. They are partly why so many Americans are willing to live in neighborhoods with HOA’s. Let a quasi-governmental body regulate these matters. Determine the exterior colors, make sure garbage cans are put away, have guidelines about landscaping, decorations, and driveways. Or some of these might fall under local ordinances, such as the height of the grass before it will be cut by a municipality with the bill going to the property owner.

Could such a scene I described above win a spooky Halloween house competition? Probably not as people like their Halloween decorations. But ask American homeowners what they would truly consider spooky and I suspect the answers would go beyond Halloween.

Trying to expand bus service in the Chicago suburbs

Pace has a new plan under consideration that would make bus service more plentiful in the Chicago metropolitan region:

Photo by Brett Sayles on Pexels.com

A 50% overall spike in bus service across the region is among the promises in Pace’s ambitious ReVision plan…

“Travel patterns have changed, and fewer people commute downtown every day. Public input and ridership trends show growing demand for nontraditional transit trips — and when we increase frequency and make our service faster, ridership grows.”

The aim is to increase ridership with more frequent buses and reduction of transit deserts in far-flung communities from rural McHenry to south suburban Cook counties…

Another priority is 50% growth on fixed routes, Pace Pulse lines on corridors like the Dempster Street Line and Cermak/22nd Street Line, as well as On-Demand service.

Given the difficulties bus service has faced in the Chicago suburbs for decades, here is what I could image would provide hope for increased ridership:

  1. Increased suburban densities. Suburban areas sprawl out from the city but a number of suburban population centers in the Chicago region have pursued denser development in their downtowns and other locations. Buses could link some of these job and residence centers where driving is currently the only option.
  2. High gas prices. When would suburbanites find it too expensive to drive everywhere and instead take advantages of bus routes when they could? It might require really expensive gasoline.
  3. A changing view of buses and mass transit compared to drive. Americans tend to drive when they have the resources to do so. They like the freedom driving offers and prefer not to be with others. Could bus travel have a higher status in the suburbs?
  4. Increasingly bad traffic. More residents and more vehicles on the road could push people to mass transit.

And the article notes that this is possible because of funding created through the creation of the Northern Illinois Transportation Authority.

Driving is so part of American suburban life that it will be interesting to see if this expanded bus service is successful. Suburbs change – but will they change in such a way that bus travel becomes common?

The birds of prey perched above Chicagoland

I have seen a number of hawks in recent years in my suburban day to day life. They are often perched in trees but I have also seen them on posts. Apparently I am not alone:

Photo by Mohan Nannapaneni on Pexels.com

Much like coyotes who have figured out how to live, hunt and grow in a metropolitan area of nearly 10 million people, certain raptors have found a way to survive here, and in some instances thrive, while enlisting the help of the towering street lamps and similar infrastructure, including cell phone towers and electric poles.

Drive long enough on Chicago-area highways or tollways and motorists may see a red-tailed hawk or a Cooper’s hawk, or at times something more exotic, perched high above the pavement on a light pole taking a rest or eyeing the medians and shoulders for the movement of a squirrel, rabbit, songbird or any other creature that could be a meal…

In addition to hawks, amateur wildlife photographer Jeff Nelson has spotted owls, osprey and peregrine falcons on poles in the region and elsewhere in northern Illinois in recent years…

Candy Ridlbauer of the Northern Illinois Raptor & Education group near Rockford said grassy medians and shoulders along roads are nicknamed “corridor cafes” for the birds of prey given the creatures that are often there that can be eaten. But there are a lot of “hazards being that close to roadways,” principally cars and trucks, she said.

This reminds me of several previous discussions here:

  1. I remember the book Welcome to Subirdia which I discussed years ago. It sounds like these birds have adapted to metropolitan environments in ways that they can navigate the real dangers – such as vehicles – and make homes.
  2. With the emergence of coyotes in the region came concerns from residents about threats to pets and yards. This article does not mention any residents expressing concerns about birds of prey. Might their presence affect human activity?
  3. How can we think about nature in the suburbs, a place that exists in part because people wanted to be closer to nature but also shapes nature in particular forms? Critics often suggest suburbs have ruined nature. Find a proposal for a new suburban development and you can often find a reaction that such land should be saved because of trees or wetlands or wildlife. Yet many suburbanites appreciate their lawns, gardens, and all the nature around them.

And one new thought: if there are more hawks and ospreys and owls in the Chicago suburbs, does this change any of the way suburbanites see their communities or surroundings? Think school mascots or what they might show visitors to the community or what they might teach kids about wildlife around them. This could slowly change over the years if residents get used to seeing these birds around.

How PR firms for data centers approach suburbanites

What might help convince suburban residents that a data center is a good fit for their community?

Photo by Jacoby Clarke on Pexels.com

Experts say that certain data center PR tactics, like preparing responses for a national day of protest or building a website that allows residents to submit comments, work for any project. But they stress that every community has its own unique soft spots and tension points. The playbook that used to work in small towns and rural areas may not apply to the suburban bedroom communities where increasing numbers of data centers are now popping up.

“You kind of have a more sophisticated residency there—folks with more money, more resources, more time to spend on fighting these developments coming in,” Waitkunas said on the podcast. Years ago, a data center company could donate a quarter of a million dollars to the local school and everyone would be happy. But these days, “given the tax base that these local communities have and the demographics of the community, just simply writing a check isn’t going to make it a seamless process.” Instead, a data center might pledge to start a conservation project or build a new park—things wealthier towns appreciate more than a few hundred thousand dollars.

In the second paragraph cited, I hear several features of suburbs that data center firms have to contend with:

  1. Concerned suburban residents can keep data centers out. They have resources and political voice. They can mobilize to stop development that they do not like.
  2. Suburban communities are not swayed just by having a new business in the community (jobs, property taxes, status, etc.) or money; they want additional contributions to the well-being of their community (like parks or green spaces).
  3. The paragraph seems to be primarily describing wealthier suburbs who can be selective about their land use and the businesses they have in their community. The data center firms have to make a strong case that they enhance this already high-status community.

These strike me as unique features for a subset of suburban communities. I have not seen opposition to data center broken down by community type but I imagine a range of kinds of suburban communities – working-class, edge city, bedroom suburb, master-planned community, industrial suburb, etc. – would have a range of responses to data centers. Convincing a wealthier and smaller suburb that a data centers makes sense for them could be a very different pitch compared to other suburbs.

And if PR firms and data center firms know this, how much will they continue to try to build data centers in wealthier suburbs? Why not target land or properties in other kinds of communities that might be more receptive to data centers?

Sprawling development and a right to darkness

American places – and global settings as well – are less dark than in the past:

Photo by Camilo on Pexels.com

Every year, the night sky is becoming 10% brighter. Eighty per cent of people live under light-polluted skies. And while the UN declared a healthy environment – clean air, clean water – to be a human right, I believe we also all have a right to darkness as well…

To preserve the darkness would mean rules and enforcement around the warmth of the lights, where they point, and how bright they can be. It would mean not putting in three lights when one would do. If we recognized that darkness is something we need, we’d become more careful about chasing it away.

Some communities have already done this. Flagstaff, Arizona, was the first city to have outdoor lighting rules, adding them in 1958. In 2001, Flagstaff became the first recognized Dark Sky City. Their rules regulate how much light can be used, what type, and where it can shine.

Other cities and towns in the US and abroad have followed. New York state is now considering a Dark Skies Protection Act, which would add restrictions on outdoor lighting – including some that would affect the city that never sleeps. All it takes to preserve the night near you is the desire to protect it with a new zoning law or, perhaps, a rule for how bright car headlights can be.

It could be helpful to look at why American skies are brighter than in the past. Here are multiple possible reasons:

  1. Concern for safety. As Americans feared crime for decades, lighting was part of the solution.
  2. More development which equals more housing, roads, and spaces to light for human activity.
  3. Different expectations and standards for spaces. How have building codes changed regarding lighting? How do people perceive darkness now compared to the past (see #1 above)?
  4. Less engagement with nature or natural settings. Could be more screens, less walking and more driving, different modes of engagement with nature.

If Americans want darker skies or the right to dark skies, how might they then also address these other issues?

I understand the concern as a street light sits along the residential road in my front yard and the back yard has a bright light shining from an HOA building behind our back yard. With all the direct light plus the metropolitan light, it takes work and travel to find spaces where one can enjoy the dark and the night sky.

But would neighbors, the nearby HOA, and the suburb I live in want to decrease their light use or land use or change their regulations? It would take sustained collective effort to make these suburban skies dark.